Showing posts with label Awards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Awards. Show all posts

Monday, January 12, 2009

Swift Reads 4: Weblog Awards Discoveries

Some, like Pia Zadora and Milli Vanilli, achieve recognition in their lifetimes, while others, like President Bush and, apparently, this modest blogger, will only be judged by history when "we'll all be dead." But as I come to terms with the likelihood of being a three-time Weblog Award loser, I prefer to think of the positive aspects of this emotionally wrenching experience: the new readers who graced my blog with their presence and the new blogs I discovered.

Although I am grateful for every one of the new readers who visited this blog in the last week, I am especially surprised and delighted with one new reader in particular who finally decided to drop in. For years she adamantly refused to read my blog or even mention my pseudonym even as she said the most scurrilous things about me. I'm not sure why she resisted coming here for so long unless it was because she was afraid that my writing was so persuasive and reasonable it would shake the very foundations of her carefully constructed world view and set off a dangerous logic loop in her brain that would cause it to short circuit. For many years she remained steadfast in her refusal to let one word of my prose sully the purity of her thoughts. But perhaps the evenings in Madison, Wisconsin, are particularly cold and lonely this time of year and perhaps she had had one too many glasses of wine by 5:30 p.m. on January 8, 2009. And so that evening, as a bitter wind howled outside her window, she checked her Sitemeter to see how many visitors Instapundit had sent her that day and saw yet another link from my site, just sitting there enticingly, beckoning, whispering, "Click me. Click me." Imagine the inner turmoil she experienced as she tried with all her might to resist clicking on the link. Must. Not. Read. Jon. Swift. Then her will power failed her and she could no longer resist, and throwing all caution to the wind, she finally succumbed and clicked that fateful link that whisked her away to my blog. And soon she was reading, feeling that first rush as my prose entered her veins. Who knew it could be so good, she said to herself as one by one the words swept away the cobwebs and the dust in the attic of her cranium, cluttered with crazy theories about breast-bearing feminists, the plots of unfinished books that bored her, deep insights into American Idol episodes and even that dark corner where Bill Clinton waits, crouched lasciviously, ready to betray her all over again. And imagine that moment when her giddy anticipation was finally fulfilled and she came to the first mention of her name, right there, right there in black and light brown, her name in all its glory!: Ann Althouse. So welcome to my modest blog, Ms. Althouse. I wish you had told me you were coming and I would have tidied up the place a bit. I hope you finally found what you were looking for.

But while it was exciting to have Ms. Althouse finally drop by after so many years, it was even more thrilling to discover so many wonderful blogs I had never read before that were nominated for Weblog Awards. And so I thought I would share some of my discoveries with you. Please go and check them out. I hope you enjoy them as much as I did.

NuVision for a New Day
The diary of a lovely blind African-American woman who sees things others don't see. In this post she talks about being flirted with at a friend's birthday party and confesses, "I can be a little shallow at times when it comes to looks." By the way, are we still allowed to use the word "blind"?

Grace the Spot
A very witty blog that was an unfortunate casualty of the Wonkette juggernaut. Here she talks about the importance of being boring in a relationship. I'm beginning to suspect, however, I may have been mistaken about its being a Lebanese blog.

Army of Dude
A military blog by an Iraq veteran. In a recent five-part series, he tries to describe to those who haven't been there what it's like to hear, see, smell, touch and taste combat in Iraq.

F--- You, Penguin
Who knew that existential despair could be so irresistibly, so heart-breakingly cute?

Curious Expedition
A beautifully designed travelogue that describes such wonders as the remarkably bear-free forests of Carpathia and other places you are glad you've never been to.

Medium Large
The blog of a comic strip artist, who in the helpful animation in this post, explains "What Is Comedy?"

Ashin Mettacara
This Burmese blog has a lot of posts about people being sentenced to long prison terms there. Apparently, they are very tough on crime in Burma.

Blabbeando
I owe a big thanks to this blog, which provided me with the very useful information that plucking your eyebrows is a sign of homosexual tendencies, which has saved me from some possibly embarrassing misunderstandings.

Buckdog
Reading this Canadian blog I learned about subtle racist backlashes in Saskatchewan and that Canada actually has its own unique culture, something I was not aware of before.

Foodie at Fifteen (Now 16)

A food blog by a high school student who really should be spending less time in the kitchen fantasizing about pork bellies and more time playing video games like others his age.

Dr. Wizard's Advice for College Students
This blog explains the world in ways even a student on a rugby scholarship can understand. Here, for example, we learn why drugs are bad through illustrative metaphors.

Madam Miaow says…
Although this is a culture blog with a decidedly left-wing slant, the writer is from "across the pond," as she charmingly puts it, where they don't have as much access to fair and balanced media as we do, and she's not afraid to take on her fellow lefties on occasion.

And if that is not enough reading for you, then check out some of the other worthy blogs that were also nominated for Best Humor Blog (i am bossy, The Bloggess, YesButNoButYes, IMAO, Mattress Police, Mother May I Sleep With Treacher, The Comics Curmudgeon, My Mom is a Fob, and Boobs, Injuries and Dr Pepper), even though some of them could not resist dragging my pseudonym through the mud in their desperation to win. I forgive you all. And I even forgive you, Comics Curmudgeon, despite the fact that you took away my dream and crumpled it up like that piece of looseleaf notebook paper with the love poem to the cheerleader written on it, laughing tauntingly as you swept the long blonde hair from your face and tossed the wad of paper disgustedly into the garbage can.

Update: A coalition of two conservative blogs, who have apparently forgotten Ronald Reagan's Eleventh Commandment, is trying to wrest second place from me armed with an endorsement from The Corner. Don't let that happen. Show them that we conservatives have learned that negative campaigning doesn't work anymore. Vote for Jon Swift here.

Update 2: Ann Althouse responds by email, "That post was awfully needy. Not that I read more than the parts right around my name," and later taunts me on her site: "No wonder he's losing the Weblog Awards voting. Man up, Swift, you pussy."

Update 3: As voting winds to a close I try to impart some valuable lessons to my fellow conservatives: "If we learned anything from the last two elections, it’s that negative campaigning doesn’t work anymore. Conservatives need to come up with a positive vision for the future if we are going to win again, which is what I have tried to do. I think the voters see that my blog is about change and the future and not about just tearing my opponents down and that is why I appear to be trouncing you."

Share This Post

blinkbits BlinkList del.icio.us digg Fark Furl LinkaGoGo Ma.gnolia NewsVine Reddit Simpy Spurl TailRank YahooMyWeb

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Epic Fail

Sixth place. Sixth place! Have I not done enough for you people? Have I not done enough reporting for you, at least by Michelle Malkin's standards? Are my posts not long enough? Have I not posted semi-regularly enough? Has my conservatism not been reasonable enough? Have I not not read enough books for you? Is it really too much to ask, to ask you to Go Here and push a little button to vote for me once a day for a week? How hard could that be? And who is this Comics Curmudgeon? The answer to that last question is a very sad tale that involves not only my impending ignoble defeat but also larger issues and much more vulnerable blogs than this one who have unjustly suffered in this year's Weblog Awards.

When President Bush won two elections it restored my faith in the sanctity of the voting process. Then I met the Weblog Awards. Last year, my category was used as the staging ground for a pissing contest between liberals and conservatives, not unlike Berlin in 1948, while the other blogs in the category, including this one, were caught in the crossfire. This year the Weblog Awards have been taken hostage by a lopsided interliberal battle with equally tragic results. In the end one liberal blog has taken ceiling cat-like powers upon itself to determine who shall win and who shall lose, turning what was supposed to be a friendly competition into a mud-slinging contest so unlike the way campaigns are usually conducted in America. And while this one liberal blog stomps around the Weblog Awards like a clumsy giant, the other major liberal blogs remain pathetically silent. Well, if they won't speak up, then I will: J'accuse, Wonkette!

Wonkette's original goal was to defeat The Confluence, which was winning in its category of Best Liberal Blog. The Confluence is a PUMA blog, which are blogs written by bitter and angry former Hillary Clinton supporters who are still getting used to the idea of having a black man in the White House. (PUMA either stands for "Party Unity My Ass" or "People Unable to Mitigate their Anger," depending on whom you ask.) Now I understand that there are many people who disagree with PUMAs, but haven't they suffered enough? Hillary lost and one day they are going to figure that out. I think we should give them a little time to adjust. Just as my grandmother learned to say "colored," they'll come around. And who knows, maybe Larry Johnson at No Quarter will find that "whitey" tape he seems to have mislaid, at least in time for the next election. Who will be laughing then?

But as Wonkette soared past the other blogs in its category, it became tipsy with power and began targeting other PUMA blogs in other categories and it didn't care who got hurt in the process. Soon other categories had its carpets dirtied by Wonkette's mud-splattered wretches. In Best New Blog, the Wonketeers randomly selected a blog, ~synthesis~, which I must say is a very fine blog, and got their legions of readers, who apparently have a lot of time on their hands, to vote for it, in order to defeat UppityWoman08, but at the same time making it virtually impossible for other blogs to win. Can you imagine how these young blogs must have felt, still gaining their sea-legs in the blogosphere, happy to be recognized for their efforts with a nomination, only to have their hopes dashed and get a sad lesson in nasty blogospheric politics? My friend Blue Gal tells me, for example, that Grace the Spot, which I think is a Lebanese blog, is a very deserving blog in that category, and it was doing quite well until Wonkette struck. Grace is understandably not happy with what she called Wonkette's "spiteful shenanigans."

In Best Small Blog, by chance, Wonkette selected Rumproast, which happens to be a great blog that I have also endorsed, but does he really want to win that way? OK, maybe he does, but there are other fine blogs in that category who now don't even have a fighting chance, such as Woman Honor Thyself, who is on my blogroll and has always been very supportive and sweet to me though I know some of my liberal readers (yes, believe it or not, I do have a few!) might disagree with her politics, just as I disagree with theirs but tolerate them anyway because that's the kind of blogger I am.

Because, like Obama, I try to be friendly with those I disagree with, it is especially painful when bloggers I thought were my friends (in an Internet sort of way) send out their vast hordes to humiliate me and other bloggers who never did anything to deserve such treatment. Yes, even this modest blogger who has always considered Wonkette to be a friend of this blog, most recently when they contributed to my year-end roundup, has been a victim of their tactics. Et tu, Wonkette? When they endorsed Comics Curmudgeon, who seems to be nice enough, as Obama might say, though somewhat irascible, in the Best Humor Blog category just because he happens to write for them occasionally, it seemed like an eerie repeat of what happened last year. As I wrote to them, "You was my brother, Wonkette, you shoulda looked out for me a little bit. You broke my heart! Get the butter!" Sure, I regretted that last Brando movie reference as going over the line, but in my defense, I was angry and writing in haste.

I don't blame the bloggers of indeterminate sex at Wonkette for getting a little carried away and pushing around a few little blogs. I've been tempted to push around a few little blogs myself. And they must be feeling just a little embarrassed because they are now telling their minions to stop voting for them and vote for another liberal blog. So which one do they choose? Talking Points Memo, which hardly needs more recognition.

Even John Yon and John Bolton who once believed passionately in the Unitary Executive Theory of presidential power, are suddenly having second thoughts about whether it's a good idea to give so much power to one man, now that they have had about eight years to think about it. Wonkette needs to learn to wield its power with the same discretion that President Bush has shown. And someone has to speak up and say that in America voting is sacred and shouldn't be allowed to be hijacked by an unruly mob. Imagine if that happened in a Presidential election. I must say the reaction of the other major liberal blogs in Wonkette's category has been pitiful. But even if they are too wimpy to fight for themselves and have abdicated to Wonkette in their own category, why don't they use their vast powers of linkage to help other worthy blogs in other categories and demonstrate to Wonkette by example that power can also be used for good? Perhaps the problem is that some of them are really not that much different from Wonkette when it comes to power wielding.

Sadly, I don't have vast powers of linkage but nevertheless I will do what I can to get my lazy, apathetic, good-for-nothing readers to help out a few other blogs that would just like to emerge from this competition with a shred of their dignity intact. For a full slate of my endorsements go here, but please give the blogs below your special attention (as in my full slate of endorsements, if they contributed to my year-end roundup, links go to the post they considered to be their best of the year):

Best Hidden Gem: Pajama Pundit is doing well and is certainly deserving, but Zuky could use your help. Pajama Pundit is also competing in Best Political Coverage, where it is doing less well, as is Foreign Policy Watch and they could both use some votes.

Best Up and Coming Blog: Both Simply Left Behind and Connecting.the.Dots are good friends of this blog and both have been sadly left behind so far.

Best Midsize Blog: The Sideshow is way behind despite all that she has done for the blogosphere, you bunch of ingrates. And Scholars and Rogues deserves more votes as well.

Best Large Blog: Although several great blogs from my blogroll, including the incomparable Miss Cellania, are competing, skippy the bush kangaroo has done more for the blogosphere than any blog around and he is being trounced by Jammie Wearing Fool, who was quite rude to me when I so graciously linked to him.

Best Very Large Blog: Bitch Ph.D. is one of the few blogs I have endorsed who is actually winning so please send some votes her way so that I can claim it was all because of me.

Best Middle East or Africa: Informed Comment is in third place. C'mon.

Best UK Blog: Olly's Onions' vote total is in the two digits. I am embarrassed for all of you.

Best Technology Blog: Wetmachine deserves to make a dignified showing amidst the megablogs.

Best Video Blog: Hot Potato Mash is near the bottom despite having created all of these amazing videos.

Best Diarist: Are you going to allow Blue Girl to be Dooced?

Best Literature Blog: Diary of a Heretic, the only blogger in the category whose blog consists of her fiction, and Maud Newton are way behind a guy who writes science fiction. Is science fiction even literature?

Best Culture Blog: Barataria is second to last and I am hanging my head in shame.

Best Science Blog: Greg Laden is dead last. Now I am angry.

Best LGBT Blog: Susie Bright is holding up the rear, which would probably have a different meaning on her blog. Help her out.

Best Individual Blogger: Driftglass is in third place and needs a good push to get into first and Field Negro should be doing much better.

Best Liberal Blog: Shakesville has always been very kind about letting me crosspost there and expose its liberal readers to new ideas and Blue Gal has done yeoman's work for smaller blogs in the blogosphere. Both deserve to lose to Wonkette in style.

And, finally, because miracles do happen, vote for Jon Swift here.

Update: Wonkette has now endorsed this modest blog in a fiendishly clever attempt to subvert my righteous indignation.

Share This Post

blinkbits BlinkList del.icio.us digg Fark Furl LinkaGoGo Ma.gnolia NewsVine Reddit Simpy Spurl TailRank YahooMyWeb

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Jon Swift Nominated for a 2008 Weblog Award for Best Humor Blog

The nominations for the 2008 Weblog Awards have just been released, and I am proud and humble to discover that this modest blog is among the nominees this year for Best Humor Blog. This is the third year in a row that this blog has been nominated in this category, and like three-time Grammy Album of the Year nominee Kanye West, I feel it’s just an honor to be nominated whether I win or not. While a third loss in a row would be humiliating and personally devastating, it’s especially gratifying to be nominated in a category that includes such fine nominees as i am bossy, The Bloggess, YesButNoButYes, IMAO, Mattress Police, Mother May I Sleep With Treacher, The Comics Curmudgeon, My Mom is a Fob, Boobs, Injuries and Dr Pepper. Let me extend my congratulations to all of you. Your year will come some day, I’m sure.

This nomination is especially surprising because I left a message with Gov. Rod Blagojevich that while I know a Weblog Award is an “f---ing valuable thing,” I could not promise to do anything in exchange for a nomination. I can’t vouch for the other nominees, but I’m sure they did the right thing as well and I would hate to think their nominations are tainted by their silence.

This is a time of crisis for humor blogs. The next four years promise to be the unfunniest in our nation’s history. I am sure some people may be thinking that as a three-time nominee, this blog has too much experience, and it would be too risky to put the Weblog Award in the hands of a blog knows what it is doing when America is clamoring for a fresh young face. But while this blog has been around since way back when Barack Obama was just a freshman senator from Illinois, what this blog is really about is change. Not the scary kind of change, but reasonable change. The kind of change where the more things change, the more they stay the same, which is the kind of change you can believe in. So I hope you will keep that in mind when voting begins on Monday, January 5 in what is probably the most important Weblog Awards of our lifetimes. You can vote here once a day until January 12.

While much of the nation’s focus will understandably be on the competition for Best Humor Blog, there are also other categories, and I want to congratulate those nominees as well. I am especially pleased to note the nominees that are on my esteemed blogroll and I hope you will consider giving them your vote. Here are my endorsements in the other categories, which you can print out and take into the voting booth with you. Many of them contributed to my compilation of the best posts of the year. I urge you to visit them all. If I’ve left off anyone on my blogroll who is nominated, please let me know. And if you are wondering how on earth this blog got nominated, "The Best of Jon Swift" may, or may not, give you a clue. Update: The links below now go to the piece each blogger nominated as his or her best of the year for my roundup, if they submitted one, so that you can see the bloggers at their best. Each category link goes to the poll for that category. You can vote once a day until January 12.

Best Individual Blogger
field negro
Driftglass
Lindsay Beyerstein - Majikthise

Best Liberal Blog

Shakesville
Hullabaloo
Sadly, No!
Blue Gal
Orcinus
Wonkette
Taylor Marsh
Crooks & Liars
Glenn Greenwald's Unclaimed Territory

Best Conservative Blog
Right Wing Nut House

Best Political Coverage
Pajama Pundit
Foreign Policy Watch

Best LGBT Blog
The Bilerico Project
Pam's House Blend
Susie Bright's Journal

Best Science Blog

Greg Laden
Pharyngula


Best Culture Blog
Barataria

Best Literature Blog
Diary of a Heretic
Maud Newton

Best Diarist
Blue Girl in a Red State (Blue State)

Best Video Blog
Hot Potato Mash

Best Technology Blog
Wetmachine

Best Canadian Blog
We Move to Canada
Abandoned Stuff

Best UK Blog
Olly's Onions

Best Middle East or Africa Blog

Informed Comment

Best Major Blog (Authority over 1001)
The Moderate Voice
TBogg
Balloon Juice

Best Very Large Blog (Authority between 501 and 1,000)
Bitch PHD
Pandagon
Jesus General

Best Large Blog (Authority between 301 and 500)
Miss Cellania
Bloggasm
skippy the bush kangaroo
The Agonist
Fafblog
Fausta's Blog

Best Midsize Blog (Authority between 201 and 300)
Betsy's Page
The Sideshow
Scholars And Rogues
Suburban Guerilla
Hoyden About Town

Best Small Blog (Authority between 101 and 200)
Woman Honor Thyself
Rumproast

Best Up And Coming Blog (Authority between 51 and 100)
Simply Left Behind
Connecting the Dots

Best Hidden Gem (Authority between 0 and 50)
Zuky
The Pajama Pundit

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Two Years Before the Masses

I am hard at work assembling my end-of-the year round-up of what bloggers on my blogroll believe are their best posts of 2007 (if you are on my blogroll -- or want to be -- and you haven't sent me a link to what you think is your best post this year, get to it). But I didn't want to let this milestone go by without some comment: This week this modest blog turned two, which is practically middle-aged in blog years.

I'm usually not very good at remembering anniversaries. I got in a bit of trouble one year when Mrs. Swift asked me if I remembered that today was our anniversary and I answered, "Anniversary of what?" It only occurred to me that this week was my blogiversary when Ed Morrissey of Captain's Quarters interviewed me for his Heading Right radio show and asked me when I started this blog, and even then I got the date wrong. Oh, did I mention I was going to be interviewed? See, I told you I was absent-minded. Anyway, if you're interested, you can listen to the show here. I make my entrance shortly after the half-hour mark.

This blog was born on December 17, 2005 with three short posts -- "War on Hanukkah," "Intelligent Design," and "Gay Mariage" -- which still remains my record for number of posts in one day. The "War on Hanukkah" piece was written when I was still Jewish, before I saw The Chronicles of Narnia and became a Born-Again Christian. I am still looking for the chapters in the Bible about the talking fauns and other magical biblical creatures. Although I received my first reader comment the next day from one Dottore Nicolo Fantutti, The Hospital of the Broken Salve, Rome, Italy, an early hint of the international impact my blog would soon have, my first big influx of readers came when Jonah Goldberg linked to my "Google Searches" piece at The Corner. I can't tell you how much it pains me that a rift has come between us since my attempt to help him write his book Liberal Fascism was so coldly rebuffed. I wonder if he thought my attempt to lend a helping hand was itself somehow fascist.

But I soon began making other friends on the Internet. Nevada Thunder, Streak's Blog, Jesus Politics and Mark Crispin Miller's News from the Underground were the first to blogroll me. Joe Gandelman at The Moderate Voice, Glenn Greenwald, Mike Finnigan at Crooks & Liars, Pierre Tristam at Candide's Notebook, Polimom, Kevin Hayden at American Street and the folks at Bad Attitudes were early supporters. To them I will always be grateful.

My Amazon reviews soon proved popular with many non-readers if not with Amazon itself, which set about deleting as many as it could find. Alas, my reviews were also not very well received by Thomas Woods Jr., who was a bit unhappy with my review of his book The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History, and this commenter.

But as I once advised Oprah, even in the face of harsh criticism, a conservative never admits mistakes, though there are a few things I might have done differently. This year I was forced to delete my notorious April Fool's post to avoid a nasty lawsuit and I still haven't been able to confirm my exclusive report on the death of Michael Ledeen, though I think a lot of people are hoping that I will be able to confirm his death someday.

But what can you expect from a two-year-old? I prefer not to dwell on my occasional setbacks but to focus on the good things that happened this year. There was my battle, with my good friend skippy the bush kangaroo at my side, to encourage the big liberal blogs to make their blogrolls more truly liberal and help out underprivileged blogs instead of leaving it up to the government. There was my citation as the Best North American Blog in the Blogpower Awards, which were started by the U.K.'s greatest gift to the blogosphere, James Higham of Nourishing Obscurity. There was my very respectable showing in the Weblog Awards, which declared Jon Swift to be the third-funniest blog on the Internet. There was my first place award in the Writer's Block Contest for my piece "Who Needs Books?" There was my controversial but ultimately rewarding stint guest-hosting the Blog Round Up at Crooks & Liars (thank you, Mike, and welcome back). And there was my victory over Facebook, which was a victory for all Pseudonym-Americans.

As my blog enters its terrible twos what can you expect? More cat pictures? More one-line or even one-word posts? More YouTube videos? More Top Ten Lists? We are constantly innovating here and there is no telling what Jon Swift 2.0 will look like. I hope to continue violating every rule in Atrios' very helpful "Why Your Blog Sucks" post, which I fear will doom my chances of ever getting blogrolled or even linked to by him. And I hope we continue to have lively discussions in the comments, which I am forced to admit, are often better than the posts themselves. I do hope I have written a few good pieces but in the end a blog is only as good as its blogees. So to all my wonderful blogees I extend a warm and heartfelt thank you for making this blog what it is today and I hope we have at least another two years together.

Friday, November 09, 2007

Third Place

The polls have closed for the 2007 Weblog Awards and Jon Swift has officially been declared the third funniest blog on the Internet. DUmmie FUnnies came in second in the Funniest Blog category and Sadly, No! took the top prize in a landslide. It was the second win in a row for Sadly, No! and the beginning of a decidedly upward trend for this modest blog, which came in fourth last year.

I want to thank everyone who supported me as well as the seven blogs I shoved out of my way in my ruthless pursuit of the bronze: The Nose On Your Face, Laurie Kendrick, The Sneeze, i am bossy, Boobs, Injuries and Dr. Pepper, The Lawsons Do Dallas! and The Hatemonger's Quarterly, worthy competitors all. Please do me a favor and check out all of their fine blogs and leave them a nice compliment in their comments. I also want to heartily congratulate my friends at Sadly, No!, who won this battle fair and square, and thank them for being gracious and merciful enough to throw some votes my way toward the end, which was extremely generous of them. It's too bad for their side that their venerable vote-getting prowess is in inverse proportion to the Democrats'. And finally, I want to thank PJComix at Dummie FUnnies, just for being himself. I think he learned a valuable and important lesson from all of this, that winning isn't everything -- it's the only thing.

Now, third place often gets a bad rap. "First prize is a Cadillac Eldorado," said Alec Baldwin's character in the film Glengarry Glen Ross. "Second prize is a set of steak knives. Third prize is you're fired." There is a perception out there that third place is for losers. But it was pointed out to me by my dear friend Kathleen Maher (whose blog Diary of a Heretic was the dark horse candidate in the Best Literature Blog category and did spectacularly well) that in horse racing third place is called "show," and according to Woody Allen, "Eighty percent of success is just showing up." And psychologists believe that coming in third is actually better than coming in second. According to a 1995 study of Olympic athletes, those who won the bronze medal were actually happier than those who won the silver. The silver medalists were frustrated they didn't win the gold, while the bronze medalists were just happy that they didn't come in fourth. And we all know about the psychological trauma Jan Brady suffered from being the Number 2 child. So my heart goes out to DUmmie FUnnies' PJComix, the Jan Brady of humor bloggers, in what must be a difficult time for him.

Some economists also believe that third place is often better than first or second place. According to James Surowiecki, sometimes as two titans battle for first place, they just end up hurting themselves. The competition between Sony Playstation and Microsoft Xbox for video game console supremacy, for example, has left both of them bloodied and their reputations tarnished, while the number three company, Nintendo, has actually been more profitable with Wii. Nintendo "has not just survived out of the spotlight; it has thrived," says Surowiecki. "It made close to a billion dollars in profit and saw its stock price rise by sixty-five per cent. Sony's game division, by contrast, barely eked out a profit and Microsoft's reportedly lost money. Who knew bringing up the rear could be so lucrative?" I can't wait until I get my profit statement. (Ironically, Playstation 2 was advertised with a bizarre David Lynch video called "Third Place.")

In fact, third place suits this blog just fine. In Ray Oldenburg's book The Great Good Place, which I have not actually read, he says that in addition to home, which he calls the First Place, and work, the Second Place, there is The Third Place. Third places are places where members of a community gather to unwind and interact, like bars, café's, bookstores, community centers and strip joints. You might think of Sadly, No! as your home and of DUmmie FUnnies as the job you hate, but Jon Swift is The Third Place; like a friendly neighborhood bar, it's a place where everybody knows your pseudonym.

Of course, there were other blogs competing in other categories and a number of my friends, some of whom are occasional guests in the comments here, were finalists. Congratulations to all the winners, especially to the blogs on my blogroll who won their categories: Crooks & Liars for Best Video Blog, Balloon Juice for Best of the Top 250 Blogs, Tbogg for Best of the Top 251 - 500 Blogs, Woman Honor Thyself for Best of Top 501 - 1000 Blogs, Echidne of the Snakes for Best of the Top 1001 - 1750 Blogs, Creek Running North for Best of the Top 2501 - 3500 Blogs and Simply Left Behind for Best of the Top 5001 - 6750 Blogs. There were a lot of great finalists on my blogroll (congratulations to all of them, which are listed here), but I owe a special debt of gratitude for all the support I got from Whiskey Fire, Bitch Ph.D., Nourishing Obscurity, skippy the bush kangaroo, Shakesville, Susie Bright's Journal, Writers Block, Self-Styled Siren, eatbees, Three Wise Men!, Robin Slick, Michael Van Der Galien, My Left Wing, Streak's Blog, Hot Potato Mash, The Galloping Beaver, Diary of a Heretic and konagod. I don't think of us as losers; I think of us as victory challenged.

And most important of all, I want to thank Kevin Aylward, of Wizbang, and everyone who helped him out, for putting these awards together. They did a great job and showed enormous grace under pressure.

While I didn't win the coveted Weblog Award this year, I did fulfill a lifelong dream: Jon Swift made the Billboard Charts! My post "Facebook Declares War on the Blogosphere" hit Number 2 with a bullet on Billboard's Top Blog Posts Chart (see the screenshot below; click on it to make it larger). Now the name Jon Swift will be forever immortalized, along with the names of other charttoppers like that guy who wrote "Tequila."


Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

Monday, November 05, 2007

The Ralph Nader of the Blogosphere?

I realize there are more important things happening in the world than the Weblog Awards and if I knew where Pakistan was, I would probably be writing about what is happening there, or if I had a job, I might be writing about the Writers Guild strike (which, despite the fact that I believe in the beneficence of corporations and am generally opposed to labor unions, has me humming "There Is Power in a Union" and "Joe Hill" in solidarity). But it has come to my attention that some of my own readers believe you cannot vote for me for Funniest Blog, after all I have done for you, because you don't want to "split the vote," despite the fact that the leading blog, Sadly, No!, is trouncing the blog in second place, DUmmie FUnnies, by a margin of almost two to one, while I languish in fourth place. Suddenly, I find that I have become the Ralph Nader of the blogosphere. Despite all of my efforts to bring laughter and delight to you, my readers, modestly blogging my fingers to the bone, not to mention my victorious battle with Facebook on behalf of all Pseudonym-Americans, some of you have turned on me, calling me a spoiler, comparing me to perhaps the least funny, most egotistical man on Earth. How could I not feel hurt and betrayed?

I am just a little tired of people telling me that they need to "strategize" with their vote. Haven't we had enough strategizing in politics? The Weblog Awards is supposed to be fun. It's supposed to bring attention to all the fine work done by bloggers over the past year and help people discover new blogs they might not know about. I have tried to run a high-minded, positive campaign based solely on the quality of my work, but it seems that on the Internet nice guys finish fourth. Is life nothing more than a popularity contest? And if life is nothing more than a popularity contest, then why doesn't high school prepare us for that?

Now, I love the guys at Sadly, No!, despite what everyone says about them, and I believe that PJComix at DUmmie FUnnies, who has been thoroughly humiliated in his failed attempts to manipulate the vote, could learn quite a lot from my explanation of how to be funny. And, sure, it would be tragic if Sadly, No! beat DUmmie FUnnies by only 2 gazillion votes instead of 3 gazillion votes. (Update: Sadly, No! has endorsed Jon Swift.) But I would like to remind everyone that the Weblog Awards is not a two-party system. You will have ample opportunity to hold your nose and vote against the candidate you despise in the Presidential election next year, so why not vote for a blog you like this time around? Some of you might not realize it, but there are eight other blogs in contention, including this modest blog. Why not vote for one of the other eight blogs for Funniest Blog in the coming days? It seems to me there is enough love to go around. Besides Jon Swift, here are the other contenders, who all deserve your consideration:

The Nose On Your Face
Laurie Kendrick
The Sneeze
i am bossy
Boobs, Injuries and Dr. Pepper
The Lawsons Do Dallas!
The Hatemonger's Quarterly

(And if you're looking for more comedy, head on over to Newcritics, which is holding a Comedy Blogathon from November 6-11.)

But in addition to showing your love for me and others in my category, I would also like you to help out some of my friends in other categories, many of whom are losing by crushing margins, which makes me look bad as well. Help them cling to one last shred of dignity and show them that someone besides their immediate families appreciates their efforts by giving them your support. I take it as a personal insult that someone like my friend skippy the bush kangaroo, for example, is undeservedly relegated to last place in his category, Best Liberal Blog, or that my friend Hot Potato Mash is dead last in the Best Video Blog category, or that Streak's Blog, one of the first blogs ever to blogroll me, is pulling up the rear in the Best of the Top 3501 - 5000 Blogs category, or that Writers Block lacks just a few votes to pull itself out of tenth in the Best Literature Blog category. Below are the blogs on my blogroll I am endorsing in each category and their current rankings out of the 10 blogs in contention (each category title is a link to the ballot). You can vote once a day until Thursday, November 8. Do what Jesus would do and help the least among them first if you don't have a particular favorite, though please also keep in mind a few special friends of mine who aren't doing quite so badly but deserve your special consideration: Diary of a Heretic, who is only a few votes shy third place in Best Literature Blog, Susie Bright's Journal in Best LGBT Blog, Bitch Ph.D. in Best of the Top 250 Blogs and Michael Van Der Galien, who has slipped into 3rd in a very tight race for Best European Blog (Non UK).

Best UK Blog
Nourishing Obscurity (currently in 8th place)

Best Middle East or Africa Blog
Eatbees (8th)

Best Online Community
My Left Wing (8th)

Best Education Blog
NYC Educator (7th)

Best Political Coverage
Foreign Policy Watch (6th)

Best Blog
Captain's Quarters (5th)


Best Culture Blog
Self-Styled Siren (4th)

Best Diarist
Robin Slick (4th)

Best European Blog (Non UK)
Michael Van Der Galien (3rd)

Best Conservative Blog
Captain's Quarters (3rd)

Best Science Blog
Pharyngula (3rd)

Best Liberal Blog
skippy the bush kangaroo (10th)
Orcinus (9th)
Shakesville (8th)
Pandagon (6th)
Glenn Greenwald's Unclaimed Territory (4th)
Hullabaloo (3rd)

Best Video Blog
Hot Potato Mash (10th)
Crooks & Liars (2nd)

Best Literature Blog
Writers Block (10th)
Erik Hare (8th)
Classical Bookworm (7th)
Maud Newton (6th)
Diary of a Heretic (4th)

Best LGBT Blog
Republic of T (9th)
Fetch me my axe (7th)
Susie Bright's Journal (5th)
Pam's House Blend (3rd)

Best of the Top 250 Blogs
MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy (9th)
Bitch Ph.D. (6th)
Jesus' General (4th)
Balloon Juice (1st)

Best of the Top 251 - 500 Blogs
Fausta (9th)
The Moderate Voice (8th)
Feministe (4th)
The Carpetbagger Report (2nd)
Tbogg (1st)

Best of the Top 501 - 1000 Blogs
Avedon Carol's The Sideshow (8th)
The Smirking Chimp (6th)
Agonist (4th)
The Poor Man Institute (3rd)
Woman Honor Thyself (1st)

Best of the Top 1001 - 1750 Blogs
Dispatches from the Culture Wars (7th)
Newshoggers (6th)
Slacktivist (4th)
Obsidian Wings (2nd)
Echidne of the Snakes (1st)

Best of the Top 2501 - 3500 Blogs
Booker Rising (8th)
A Tiny Revolution (5th)
Acephalous (4th)
driftglass (3rd)
Creek Running North (1st)

Best of the Top 3501 - 5000 Blogs
Streak's Blog (10th)
Prometheus 6 (9th)
(parenthetical remarks) (8th)
Ken Levine (6th)
Dr. Joan Bushwell's Chimpanzee Refuge (4th)
The Galloping Beaver (2nd)

Best of the Top 5001 - 6750 Blogs
Gay Orbit (10th)
Three Wise Men! (8th)
The Field Negro (6th)
The Debate Link (5th)
Simply Left Behind (2nd)
Whiskey Fire (1st)

Best of the Top 6751 - 8750 Blogs
Reno and Its Discontents (10th)
HE&OS--Home Education & Other Stuff (9th)
Abnormal Interests (8th)
Jack and Jill Politics (5th)
Scholars & Rogues (4th)

Best of the Rest of the Blogs (8751+)
Kiko's House (6th)
Political Grind (5th)
konagod (3rd)


Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Sunday, November 04, 2007

Swift Reactions 5

This was quite a week for this modest blog. We were nominated for a 2007 Weblog Award for Funniest Blog (if you haven't voted for us yet today, go here and vote now before you read any further; we'll wait here until you get back). And our victory over Facebook (which was a victory for all Pseudonym-Americans) has brought us so many encomiums, citations for bravery, proposals of marriage, and the like, that it would just be too tedious to mention each and every one of them. But for this edition of "Swift Reactions" I don't want to focus on me but on you, my dear readers. Like a proud parent, I was happy to see that in the course of heaping great amounts of praise upon me, many of those writing about my battle with Facebook had some very nice things to say about my commenters as well.

"Some of the comments on Jon’s post about this are truly wonderful," said Lee Hopkins, who went on to cite a comment left by g4rg4ntu4: "I’m appalled at how unprofessional these farcebook people are. I myself had a similar problem when I tried to create an account under my pseudonym (g4rg4ntu4). After much harassment and threatened litigation I had no choice but to go with my real name (which of course is Francois Rabelais)." Hopkins also quoted Norman P, who wrote, "When I read your post this morning, I asked myself as I always do, 'What would Jesus do?' But you’ve noted that there are 500 people named Jesus Christ on Facebook, which means that I may very well get 500 different answers," and Gwyneth Llewelyn (not her "real name"), who believes that Facebook's discrimination against Pseudonym-Americans and pseudonymous people from around the world is actually a violation of international law: "Pseudonyms have established legal rights. Refusing to accept a pseudonym is actually more illegal than breaking a ToS [terms of service agreement] that is, by itself, in contravention of international copyright laws." I also want to cite Code Red, one of the hardest-working commenters we have ever had here, who did some digging and created an exhaustive list of links to other Facebook accounts under such "real" names as Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, John Wayne, George Bush and the Gingerbread Man.

As painful as this whole ordeal was for me, one of the things I learned this week that gave me hope for the future was how respectful many people, especially young people, are of rules nowadays. It was very refreshing to discover that so many people believe that all rules should be obeyed and enforced no matter how absurd and arbitrary those rules may be. More and more it seems we are living in a society that is, as I once said of Guantanamo, Kafkaesque in a good way. "Providing your real name is a very clear very upfront part of the Facebook TOS," wrote Jen Flanigan, whose writings, which she posts on the Internet under her real name, will haunt her for the rest of her life. "Bottom line is that you agreed to that TOS when you signed up and you violated it. Whether you like it or not, Facebook has the right to enforce that. You don't have a leg to stand on, whether the policy makes you happy or not." John (yes, that John) agreed: "If you don't want to use your real name, don't use services that require it. Facebook is a private company, not a public utility, and can make whatever rules they want." A number of the commenters at this Wired article on my plight were also squarely on the side of Facebook. They seem to be the kind of people who know every obscure rule in the Official Scrabble Rule Book and are vigilant about challenging any word that may skirt those rules.

Believe it or not, though, there are times when I wonder whether I should start requiring people to use their real names in my comments. That thought occured to me when I read some of the comments to my piece "Steven Boylan Is Not a Moron," where I proved that Col. Boylan could not have written the email sent to Glenn Greenwald, using what Tom Bozzo described as "Aristotelian logic," which is some of the best logic you can use. "Seriously? That's the basis of your defense of Boylan? That he could not *possibly* be a moron?" asked Barry, who is apparently not a great fan of Aristotle. Lefty, a new visitor to my blog, was also not convinced, writing, "To say that you can't imagine [Boylan] being this stupid means you are so far behind the curve that I'd have to seriously question your judgement of anything else you ever post."

When I failed to respond to Lefty's arguments in a timely fashion, he left another comment: "I will assume your lack of response like the good Colonel's betrays a lack of a defense. Moron." I patiently explained to Lefty that I rarely make it down to the cellar of my blog where the comments are kept because my commenters do such a good job that my presence would be superfluous. And besides I find it to be a little dark and dank down there for my taste. I also took issue with his use of the word assume: "Didn't your mother ever teach you never to assume because it makes 'a ss of u and me'?" I asked him. "I'm not sure what a 'ss' is, but I always assumed it was something I didn't want to be, though if I had learned my lesson well I wouldn't have assumed anything at all, I suppose."

A number of commenters on my post announcing my Weblog Award nomination for Funniest Blog were puzzled that I was nominated in that category since my blog is only unintentionally funny. Autumnal Harvest, however, supplied a very logical explanation: "Other commenters here have noted the oddity of your nomination for 'Funniest blog,' rather than 'Best conservative blog.' I was myself a little confused by this, since, looking through your blog, you seem to only very rarely make jokes or engage in satire--and really, although it pains me to say this, your jokes are very rarely funny, and you should restrict yourself to your insightful conservative commentary. However, I have noticed that often in the comments to your posts, there are comments by angry liberals who take issue with your commentary. These comments are extremely funny, since I often feel that these angry liberals have failed to understand that fine points you make in your posts. And angry liberals are always funny! Perhaps these comments are responsible for your nomination as 'funniest blog'?" So what AH is saying, in other words, is that when you vote for Jon Swift for Funniest Blog, you are really voting for yourself.

It warmed my heart to see so many kind words wishing me good luck in the comments to this post, but in the end, I must say, words are cheap. I am losing and losing badly and it's not just embarrassing for me but embarrassing for all of you as apparently your efforts to help me win have been such a miserable failure. Surely, you can do better than that.

Now, I don't want to say anything bad about DUmmie FUnnies, the blog that is currently in the lead in the Funniest Blog category, but like Glenn Reynolds of Instapundit, I don't mind linking to someone who does have something bad to say about my esteemed opponent, like this post at Sadly, No, for example. Instead, I plan to stay high-minded and above the fray, a strategy that also seems to be working out quite well for Barack Obama.

It's bad enough that I am losing pathetically in my category, but even worse is that many of the blogs I endorsed are also being trounced in their categories. Many of these bloggers are under the impression that I have some power and influence in the blogosphere, but when they see that an endorsement from me makes so little difference, their dreams of succeeding by sucking up to me will be cruelly shattered. Please let them know that their efforts to flatter me and shower me with gifts have not been in vain and go right now to vote for these fine blogs (some categories have more than one Jon Swift-approved choice):

Best UK Blog
Nourishing Obscurity

Best Culture Blog
Self-Styled Siren

Best Middle East or Africa Blog
Eatbees

Best European Blog (Non UK)
Michael Van Der Galien

Best Literature Blog
Diary of a Heretic
Writers Block
Maud Newton
Classical Bookworm
Erik Hare

Best Diarist
Robin Slick

Best Education Blog
NYC Educator

Best Video Blog
Hot Potato Mash
Crooks & Liars

Best LGBT Blog
Susie Bright's Journal
Republic of T
Pam's House Blend
Fetch me my axe.

Best Political Coverage
Foreign Policy Watch

Best Science Blog
Pharyngula







The 2008 Weblog Awards

Google